Stones are listed in no particular order:
TYLER
Franklin H., son of S & E, died Mar. 21, 1851, AE. 4y 7m 11d “F.H.T.”
STANNARD
Wm. Chauncy, son of Wm. & N, died Jan. 23, 1847, AE. 5y 5m 2d
2 Infants, died Feb. 9, 1845 & Jan. 11, 1849
ZIMMERMAN
Charles R., son of Daniel & Elizabeth, died Sept. 13, 1859, aged 23ds
Also our little one, died Aug. 21, 1857
PELTON
Philander, son of P & L, who died Oct. 2d, 1828, aged 4y & 6m
CHASE
Caleb, died May 28, 1847, aged 51 years
WELTON
Caroline, wife of Dr. W.S.H. and daughter of G & D Crocker, died Apr. 12, 1860, aged 44 years 6ms & 6ds
WELTON
Children of Wm. S.H. & C.:
Leroy, died Jan. ?1, 18??, aged 1yr & 10m*
Emily S., died Apr. 20, 18?2, aged 2 yrs ???
* – Wolcott shows this as Leroy Welton, child of William S.H. & C, died Jan. 24, 1845, AE. 1y 10m.
MORSE
Phebe, wife of Friend M., died March 12, 1847, aged 77 years 5mo “P.M.”
UNKNOWN
James M., died ????
This might be the stone for James Martin, died Mar. 18, 1838, aged 35ys 9m. Wolcott recorded the stone as being in the Pelton iron enclosure (since lost).
BUNKER
Joseph, died Nov. 16, 1860, aged 45ys 10m
PELTON
Jonathan, son of P & L, who died Oct. 7th, 1825, (aged 11 yrs & 9m)
Information in parentheses taken from Wolcott’s inscriptions. No longer visible on headstone.
BADGER
Catherine, wife of Austin, died July 30, 1822, aged 25 years “C.B.”
(Catherine Badger’s original headstone is still here also. It is very worn but reads: “Catharine, wife of Austin Badger, who died July 30th “. The rest of the stone is unreadable. Note that the spelling of her first name is different on each stone. Her name also appears on a headstone with her husband and his other wives in the Old Medina Cemetery in Medina, Ohio. That engraving spells her name as `Catharine’ but gives her age as 21 years. The inscription confirms that she is buried in Montville, Ohio.)
SMITH
R. Berthier, son of R.B. & M.E., died Oct. 25, 1845, aged 3 yrs
WILBUR
Laura B., wife of Halsey and daughter of F.M. & P. (Morse, died Aug. 12, 1857, AE. 45y)
(Information in parentheses taken from Wolcott’s inscriptions.)
TILLOTSON
Mary A., dau. of P.D. & M.L., died Aug. 9, 1848, AE. 6 yrs 1mo 7ds
PARSONS
Ellen, daughter of J & P, died Mar. 17, 1840, ag’d 11 y’rs
BADGER
Mary S., wife of Austin, died Sep. 14, 1852, aged 51 yrs 1mo 17ds
(Her name appears on a headstone with her husband and his other wives at Old Medina Cemetery in Medina, Ohio. That engraving gives her middle initial as `L’ but confirms that she is buried in Montville, Ohio.)
Stone reads only: “LITTLE HAMER’S GRAVE”
(Wolcott shows this is likely a stone for Ithamer Pelton, son of Isaac W. Pelton, born 1845, died 1849.)
UNKNOWN
?????, died Feb. 20, 1849, aged 48 yrs
DOWNING
John, died Feb. 10, 1861, aged 67 years
PELTON
Infant, daughter of P & O.P., died Sep. 18, 1850
PELTON
Mary W., wife of I.W., daughter of A & D Barnard, died May 6, 1850, aged 27 yrs
Mary also appears on a headstone with her husband and his second wife in Spring Grove Cemetery in Medina, Ohio. Spring Grove’s records show no mention of her so we can assume that she is still buried here.
PELTON
H.C., died Dec. 16, 1863, AE. 43 y’rs
PELTON
Romelia P., wife of John P., died April 3, 1849, aged 17 years “R.P.P.”
Also an infant son
WELTON
Hon. Philo, died Sep. 19, 1852, aged 70 years
WELTON
Sina, wife of Philo, died Oct. 27, 1855, aged 69 years
SMITH
Alton B., son of I & A, died March 15, 1838, aged 20 years “A.B.S.”
SMITH
Anna, wife of Ithamar, died Aug. 8, 1854, aged 80 y’rs
SMITH
Ithamer, died March 3d, 1860, aged 86 y’rs “I.S.”
SMITH
Fairfax, died Jan. 30th, 1847, ag’d 59 years “F.S.”
Abigail, wife of F., died Sept. 3, 1852, aged 61 y’rs
The above is from the obelisk. Fairfax and Abigail each have separate headstones as well. They read as follows:
“Fairfax Smith, died Jan. 30, 1847, aged 59 years”
“Abigail, wife of F. Smith, died Sept. 3, 1852, aged 61 yrs”
(Despite the presence of two monuments for each of them, they are no longer buried in this cemetery. Their bodies were first moved to their son Linus’s private burial vault and then in 1894 to Spring Grove Cemetery in Medina (Section 4, Lot 104).)
CROCKER
Clara D., dau. of J.M. & M.D., died Jan. 18, 1849, AE. 6 mos
UNKNOWN
???????, aged ?y & ?m
MORSE
Frend M., died Feb. 6, 1861, aged 86 y’rs 3 mo
MORSE
Obadiah, died March 17, 1854, aged 53 yrs
Andrew, son of O & E, died Oct. 13, 1842, AE. 10 yrs
BOOTH
Ephraim, born 1778, died Sept. 8, 1844
Nancy, his wife, born 1780, died Sept. 25, 1844
Elizabeth, born Sept. 1, 1807, died Dec. 9, 1853
Polly, aged 50 yrs
MARTIN
Jane M., daughter of J.M. & L.G., died Feb. 28, 1854, ag’d 22 y’rs “J.M.M.”
WELTON
Daughters of P & S:
Nancy B., died Oct. 5, 1823, AE. 2y 5m
Mary ?., died Oct. 7, 1823, ag’d 8mo
SHONTZ
Little Freddie, aged 4 yrs, son of A & E
STANNARD
Edwin C., died Aug. 13, 1870, aged 30ys 8 mos
STANNARD
Wm., died Jan. 15, 1853, AE. 49 y’rs “W.S.”
STANNARD
Nancy Booth, Feb. 4, 1889, 79y 8m 14d
STANNARD
Frederick H., son of W & E, died Feb. 13, 1867, aged 34 yrs
CULVER
Sidney, died Mar. 5, 1867, aged 61 yrs
Elvira, the wife, died May 29, 1880, aged 68 years
HARRIS
Sarah, died May 6, 1883, aged 50y 10m 29d
Wm. W., died Mar. 22, 1890, aged 62 yrs 4ds
Aaron, died May 9, 1872, aged 76 years, father
Elliner, wife of Aaron, died Sept. 16, 1882, aged 84 yrs 11ds, mother
PELTON
Parker, died March 18, 1849 in the 60 year of his age
PELTON
Laura, wife of Parker, died Sept. 12, 1870, aged ????
NOTE: She was age 61 in the 1850 Montville Twp. census; age 70 in 1860.
ALSO KNOWN TO BE BURIED HERE…
PELTON
Infant daughter of P & L, who died Nov. 3, 1830 – taken from Wolcott’s inscriptions for this cemetery; no headstone can be found now.
BADGER
Nancy, wife of Austin, died Mar. 5, 1849, aged 47y – taken from the MCGS book inscriptions; no headstone can be found now. Her name appears on a headstone with her husband and his other wives at the Old Medina Cemetery in Medina, Ohio. The inscription confirms that she is buried in Montville, Ohio.
SMITH
“In memory of Francis R.”, son of R.B. & M.E., died Oct. 18, 1845, AE. 15m – taken from Wolcott’s early Montville burials list. A brother by the same parents who died the same year within a few days is buried here. We assume this child would be also.
FORMERLY BURIED HERE…
SMITH
Albert, son of Linus & Julia, born 1855, died July 13, 1862 – his body was eventually reinterred in his father’s burial vault on the family property. It was later stolen from that vault but recovered. He is now buried in Spring Grove Cemetery (Section 4, Lot 104); having been moved there along with his parents in 1894. We can assume he was originally buried here since the burial vault was not built until 1879.
(Source: Jane Effinger Corbus, Smith descendent)