Graves are listed north to south.
Lot 1
Lot 2
Lot 3
LANDRUM
Reva P., 1924-1982, mother
Lot 4
HARMON
Jerry Henry Jr., husband, father, Mar. 10, 1937 – Apr. 30, 1991
HARMON
Sylvia Diana, wife, mother, Jan. 18, 1940 – Mar. 8, 2012
HARMON
Jase Hale, Sept. 15, 1971 – June 7, 1980
Lot 5
HEESTAND
Wilbur D., U.S. Naval Air Force, 1929-1955
Stanley K., World War II, 1914-1944, buried in France
McCARTNEY
Helen Heestand, July 16, 1920 – Dec. 24, 2010
WALKER
Genevieve Elizabeth Heestand, 1917-1987
LANDRUM
Joseph J., 1875-1956
Lot 6
HEESTAND
Lovina, 1864-1957
Treva A.M., 1905-1976
BROWAND
Aaron J., 1894-1970
Hazel M., 1899-1961
Lot 7
Lot 8
Lot 9
Lot 10
Lot 11
Lot 12
For lots 13-36, the graves in the western half of the lot are listed in the top; burials for the eastern half are listed in the lower part.
Lot 13 (west)
Lot 13 (east)
Lot 14 (west)
NOLT
Jacob, May 20, 1867 – April 1, 1931
NOLT
Anna H., Dec. 19, 1868 – May 24, 1953
SHEPHERD
Ellen, 1895-1987
Lot 14 (east)
NOLT
Enos D., 1892-1964
Edna L., 1898-1991
NOLT
Melville T., Feb. 19, 1925 – Nov. 28, 1967
Lot 15 (west)
FINDLEY
Susan, 1858-1934
Ephraim, 1854-1935
FRIEND
Samuel M., Nov. 28, 1861 – Feb. 6, 1943
Emma C. Justice, Feb. 28, 1863 – Feb. 19, 1940
Lot 15 (east)
Lot 16 (west)
BOLDMAN
Guy C., 1884-1966
Ida Mae, 1880-1949
BOLDMAN
Clyde A., Nov. 6, 1909 – Nov. 6, 1995
ORR
John, 1877-1957
Bernice P., 1905-1948
Lot 16 (east)
Lot 17 (west)
HEESTAND
Perry A., 1884-1943
Mildred, 1894-1977
SHOEMAKER
Lorin, 1860-1940
Ida M., 1869-1950
Lot 17 (east)
Lot 18 (west)
BROWAND
Elmer E., 1866-1950
Elizabeth, 1872-1954
Lot 18 (east)
BROWAND
Maria, 1843-1938
Aaron, 1838-1928
HUBER
Arlene Mae Browand, September 25, 1936 – no death date
Lot 19 (west)
SHANK
Joseph C., 1883-1964
Della M., 1890-1985
Infant children, no dates*
* – a death certificate can be found showing that one of these children was an infant daughter, born June 18, 1928 and dying June 19, 1928. A Vital Statistics List in the July 25, 1930 edition of the Medina Gazette (pg. 6) refers to an Infant Shank that was stillborn on June 6, 1930. No other details are given but it is a possible match.
Lot 19 (east)
Lot 20 (west)
GARVER
Jesse G., Apr. 13, 1904 – Aug. 31, 1968
Ruth M., Oct. 11, 1913 – July 25, 1989
GARVER
Glenn, 1900-1990
May M., 1907-1950
Lot 20 (east)
Lot 21 (west)
CRANDALL
Martha J., 1875-1953, mother
DAVIS
Marcella C., 1910-1980
Orlett B., 1913-1992
DAVIS
Jessica Lynn, Jan. 31, 1983
Lot 21 (east)
Lot 22 (west)
Lot 22 (east)
Lot 23 (west)
Lot 23 (east)
Lot 24 (west)
Lot 24 (east)
Lot 25 (west)
GUGGINO
Frank Nicholas, June 17, 1960 – May 16, 1978
FINDLEY
Lowell Quinter, May 20, 1940 – Feb. 12, 1974
FINDLEY
Quinter F., 1914-1952
H. Lenore, 1913-1988
Lot 25 (east)
Lot 26 (west)
ELDRED
Walter P., March 22, 1908 – February 22, 1932
McVICKER
William J., 1880-1962
Mary E., 1883-1975
Lot 26 (east)
Lot 27 (west)
FINDLEY
Kenneth Wayne, Jan. 20, 1905 – Aug. 6, 1974
Naomi Santos, his wife, Apr. 16, 1917 – no death date
FINDLEY
F. Lemmon, 1882-1968
Maggie M., 1882-1951
Lot 27 (east)
Lot 28 (west)
HARTSOUGH
Frank F., 1883-1960
Grace E. Meyers, his wife, 1889-1933
MEYERS
Isaac M., 1854-1929
Emma, 1862-1929
Lot 28 (east)
Lot 29 (west)
Lot 29 (east)
GARVER
Jacob H., 1852-1930
Ida M., his wife, 1856-1950
Lot 30 (west)
Lot 30 (east)
GARVER
John F., May 19, 1860 – Nov. 7, 1930
GARVER
Dora May Dean, his wife, Sept. 8, 1865 – June 30, 1938
Lot 31 (west)
PARKHILL
Amanda, 1849-1928, mother
GARVER
Pauline Hough, 1910-1994
Lot 31 (east)
BROWAND
Ethel Garver White, 1897-1983
GARVER
Daniel B., 1863-1951
GARVER
Flora E. Parkhill, his wife, 1874-1930
Lot 32 (west)
WERTZ
William P., 1867-1952
Della M., 1869-1949
Lot 32 (east)
DICKEY
Lydia A. Wertz, 1860-1950
WERTZ
John M., 1894-1986, brother
Clara E., 1903-1987, sister
Lot 33 (west)
MEYERS
Allen H., 1892-1943
Josephine J., 1893-1979
Lot 33 (east)
Lot 34 (west)
FELVER
Roy W., 1910-1959
Lot 34 (east)
Lot 35 (west)
ROSE
James R., Jan. 1, 1932 – July 31, 1990
ROSE
Jack Jr., 1929-1971
Isabelle, 1931 – no death date
Lot 35 (east)
Lot 36 (west)
ROUTH
Kale J., June 6, 1918 – Apr. 19, 1996
Mada L., Sept. 22, 1919 – Oct. 13, 1998
married Sept. 6, 1941
Lot 36 (east)
Lot 37
Lot 38
Lot 39
GRISSINGER
Pheobe, 1846-1922
Joseph, 1849-1926
ORR
Mary, 1880-1968
Samuel, 1872-1942
Lot 40
ROSS
Hazel A., 1891-1970
Charles H., 1894-1955
ROSS
Seth Peter, 1867-1942
(A blank footstone was put here by someone to mark the grave along with a metal funeral home marker. The metal marker has been badly damaged and cannot be read anymore. The information here is from the MCGS book listing for this location. His death certificate shows he was born December 16, 1867, died January 20, 1942.)
Lot 41
MEYERS
Edna I., Jan. 20, 1896 – Dec. 10, 1969
Paul E., Dec. 3, 1894 – Oct. 9, 1970
Lot 42
Lot 43
ALLEN
Otto E., 1888-1967
Olive S., 1889-1980
Lot 44
BILLMAN
Kermit C., S Sgt. U.S. Army World War II, Nov. 14, 1923 – Feb. 12, 1979
BILLMAN*
Ruth Mildred Blackhall, wife of Kermit C., December 17, 1925 – May 12, 2008
* – no headstone; information obtained from her obituary in the Gazette. Exact location assumed.
BILLMAN
Clayton L., 1887-1962
Della M., 1891-1976
married Jan. 1, 1910
KNIGHT
D. Russell, 1900-1965
Ida B., 1910-1984
Lot 45
Lot 46
Lot 47-A
LEINARD
Elizabeth, died Nov. 6, 1871, aged 95 yrs
WELLE
Sarah, mother, July 22, 1834 – Sept. 28, 1908
Lot 47-B
FISHER
Christianna, wife of Geo., died Feb. 17, 1880, aged 69ys 8m 26d
FISHER
George, died Oct. 31, 1884, aged 77 yrs 17ds
HANGE
Christianna, wife of George, 1847-1915, mother
HANGE
George, died February 10, 1884, aged 35 years*
* – no headstone; information obtained from his death record. No information has been found indicating his burial anywhere but there is a good chance it was here. He died in Chatham and this lot was already being used by his wife’s parents (the Fishers). His wife was later buried here also.
Lot 47-C
CULP
Infant son of S.G. & M, born July 4, 1872
CULP
Samuel G., died July 16, 1880, aged 36y 2m & 30d
Lot 48-A
FISHER*
John, 1838-1900
FISHER*
John, no dates
Nancy, no dates
* – these appear to be two markers for the same John Fisher. Nancy’s fate is unclear as she appears in the 1900 Chatham census at the age of 63 years but no further information on her whereabouts could be located.
Lot 48-B
BLACK
Elisabeth, died May 23, 1886, aged (stone broken along age, not readable)
WOODS
Charles Homer, son of Mr. & Mrs. P.A., Sept. 2, 1914
Lot 48-C
BOWMAN
Ethel, 1897-1956
Blake, 1889-1973
BOWMAN
Evelyn E., 1895-1980
Dean H., 1887-1971
Lot 48-D
Lot 49-A
RITTENHOUSE
Joseph, died Dec. 30, 1891, aged 82y 3m & 9d, father “J.R.”
Catharine, wife of J., died May 31, 1893, aged 83y 7m 3d, mother
Lot 49-B
RITTENHOUSE
Susanna, wife of N.C., died Aug. 8, 1867, aged 36 yrs 1mo 22ds
Sarah, daughter of N.C. & S, died Jan. 1, 1864, aged 5mo 18ds
Lot 49-C
RITTENHOUSE
Emma J., dau. of J & S.E., died Dec. 18, 1871, aged 4 mos 18ds
Lot 50-A
WERTZ
Samuel, son of J & M, May 18, 1869 – Feb. 29, 1876
WERTZ
John, May 25, 1831 – Oct. 5, 1905
Margaret, his wife, Nov. 3, 1831 – Nov. 12, 1906
Lot 50-B
GRISSINGER
Cletus, 1884-1898
GRISSINGER
Infant children of Perd & Lena, no dates*
* – a death certificate can be found identifying one of these children as Oweida Grissinger, daughter of Perd & Lena, born & dying April 22, 1916. The obituary for Perd Grissinger in the December 17, 1935 Gazette (pg. 6) says that he and his wife lost two children in infancy.
GRISSINGER@
Perd, February 12, 1882 – December 6, 1935
@ – no headstone; information obtained from his death certificate and the December 13, 1935 edition of the Gazette (pg. 5) which confirm his burial in this cemetery. Presumably he is buried here alongside his children.
Lot 50-C
KREIGER
John Richard, son of I.J. & M.A., Jan. 10 – 12, 1913
BOWMAN
Jeanetta May, 1921
KRIEGER
Melissa, 1871-1973
Ira J., 1873-1948
Lot 50-D
Lot 51-A
HARTEL
Frank J., 1825-1915
Sarah A. Dague, his wife, 1826-1907
HARTLE
Jacob, died Mar. 1, 1875, aged 16ys 10ms & 9ds
HARTEL
Willey, son of F.J. & S.A., died Mar. 5, 1869, aged 1y 7m 12d
Lot 51-B
DAGE
Jonas, died June 28, 1874, aged 40ys 8ms 1d
BRILL
Caroline V., wife of David, died Apr. 9, 1876, aged 31y 22d
Lot 51-C
DAGE
Margaret, wife of Frederick, died Aug. 10, 1876, aged 77y 1m 14d
Lot 52-A
ENGLAND
Little Lula, dau. of J.I. & S.M., died Feb. 4, 1876, age 2y’s 6m’s 20d’s
GAULT
Daniel P., 1834-1906 “FATHER”
Sarah J., his wife, 1836-1919 “MOTHER”
Lot 52-B
GARVER
Jacob, Jan. 26, 1818 – May 6, 1901
ENGLAND
Job M., died Oct. 3, 1876, age 92 y’rs, father
Martha, died Jan. 4, 1864, age 74 y’rs, mother
Lot 52-C
BROWAND
Jacob, died June 2, 1862, AE. 61y 7mo 14ds
BROWAND
Elizabeth, his wife, died ??? ?22?, 1877, (stone broken)*
BROWAND
Simon, son of J & E, died June 12, 1862, AE. 28 yrs 7mo 23d
BROWAND
Aron, son of T & A, died Feb. 15, 1857, aged 1yr 4mo 15d
BROWAND
Infant son of T & A, no dates
* – Elizabeth is age 67 in the 1870 Spencer census. That would make her about 74 at the time of her death.
Lot 52-D
BAILEY
Minnie A., dau. of James B. & Mary A., died May 30, 1882, aged 2y 4m & 29d
BAILEY
James, 1843-1911 “JAMES”
Mary A. Browand, his wife, 1854-1914 “MARY”
Lot 53-A
BOLLINGER
Susannah, born Feb. 13, 1858, died Dec. 17, 1871
Nicodemas, born May 27, 1874, died Dec. 18, 1874
Emmanuel O., born Nov. 23, 1869, died Oct. 26, 1872
BOLLINGER
Anna, daughter of G & L, died Sept. 15, 1865, aged 4ys 2ms & 6ds
BOLLINGER
Jonas, son of G & L, died Feb. 24, 1857, aged 1 month
Lot 53-B
KILMER
Albert, infant son of H.E. & E, 1903, aged 4 days
KILMER
Elizabeth Hoover, 1864-1935
Henry E., 1858-1938
Lot 53-C
REINKE
Charlotte E., Feb. 4, 1914 – Jan. 24, 1991*
J. Herman, May 20, 1913 – Dec. 1, 2004
married Feb. 25, 1934
ORR
Solomon, 1876-1946
Effie Kilmer, 1885-1975
Charlotte, daughter, 1914-1991*
* – presumed to be the same person on two different headstones.
Lot 54-A
FETZER
Frank, Jan. 14, 1860 – Apr. 4, 1907
Katie Shook, his wife, Dec. 25, 1857 – Nov. 23, 1920
Lot 54-B
Lot 54-C
Lot 54-D
Lot 55-A
CLEVERDON
Harry L., son of Wm. & E, born Feb. 7, 1885, died Sept. 8, 1885
CLEVERDON
Cordie A., dau. of Wm. & E, died Dec. 29?, 1882, aged 2 yrs 8mo & 22ds
NOTE: the MCGS book lists a Harvey Cleverdon here along with the two children above. They do have a brother named Harvey but he lived well into adulthood. He and his wife (Bessie) are buried in Spring Grove Cemetery in Medina, Ohio. It is unclear who the MCGS listing refers to.
Lot 55-B
GAULT
William L., 1860-1921
GAULT
Ralph L., son of W.L. & S.J., Mar. 26, 1888 – Oct. 4, 1898
Lot 55-C
WHITE
John W., Feb. 14, 1817 – July 21, 1895 “FATHER”
Catharine, his wife, June 24, 1837 – Jan. 13, 1907 “MOTHER”
WHITE
Emma M., dau. of J.W. & C, died Oct. 24, 1886, aged 16 yrs 7m 18d
Lot 56-A
SHOOK
Jacob, July 18, 1821 – Dec. 24, 1898
Rebecca, his wife, Aug. 11, 1818 – July 14, 1906
Lot 56-B
BROVONT
Harvey, died Mar. 23, 1878, aged 11ms & 15ds
William H., died Aug. 9, 1879, aged 5ms & 17ds
Infant son of Jacob & Eliza, died Oct. 2, 1871
Lot 56-C
FLORY
Peter, 1846-1928
Ella, his wife, 1861-1906
Lot 56-D
MEYERS
Pierson E., Sept. 24, 1935 – Sept. 27, 1935
MEYERS
Ellowyn I., 1933
MEYERS
Agnes D., infant*
* – her death certificate identifies her as a daughter of Paul E. & Edna I. Meyers, stillborn on November 23, 1916.
MEYERS
Florence J., 1919
MEYERS
Merlin M., 1921
Lot 57-A
HOOVER
Tobias, 1842-1907
Mary Rittenhouse, his wife, 1846-1922
Lot 57-B
GARVER
Eld. Samuel, died May 13, 1907, aged 81y 7m & 5d, father “FATHER”
Sarah Rice, wife of Eld. Samuel, died Feb. 22, 1891, aged 67y 2m & 22d, mother “MOTHER”
YODER
Ida E., 1864-1936
John, 1861-1953
Lot 57-C
PITTENGER
John S., died Nov. 23, 1907, aged 84y 3m 1d, father
Mary Garver, wife of J.S., died May 10, 1893, aged 66y 5m 19d, mother
Lot 58-A
Lot 58-B
SHOEMAKER
William, 1832-1895
Leah, his wife, 1831-1904
Lot 58-C
HART
George H., father, 1857-1893 (His death record shows he died July 24, 1894.)
HART*
Georgie Grace, 1893-1894
HART
Samuel M., 1891-1894
* – the date of death on this stone must be wrong. The October 3, 1895 edition of the Gazette (Chatham News pg. 2) tells “Mrs. Grace Hart’s little babe died Thursday. Interment at the German Reformed Cemetery southwest of town.” This must refer to the same child.
Lot 58-D
Lot 59-A
WOODS
William, died Jan. 27, 1864, aged 43y 11m 10d “FATHER”
Catharine Berkey, his wife, died Oct. 28, 1902, aged 78y 7m 23d “MOTHER”
Lot 59-B
WOODS
Charles M., died Apr. 15, 1904, aged 40 yrs 7mos 5dys
Clara Pittenger, his wife, died Jan. 28, 1941, aged 77 yrs 11mos 13dys
Lot 59-C
BROWAND
Tobias, died Mar. 30, 1904, aged 78 yrs 7mos 5dys “FATHER”
Anna Rice, wife of Tobias, died Feb. 10, 1907, aged 78 yrs 9ms 20ds “MOTHER”
Lot 60-A
BROWAND
Floyd, May 24, 1905 – May 31, 1905
SANFORD
Arthur V., 1871-1955
Rosan, 1869-1944
Lot 60-B
SANFORD
Robert, Aug. 25, 1907
Lot 60-C
ESHELMAN
Elmer E., 1875-1959
Sadie A., 1869-1949
Lot 60-D
Lot 61
VIGILANTE
Kyle Vincent, Jan. 3, 2005
LOVETT
Roger, Aug. 2005
ALSO KNOWN TO BE BURIED HERE…
BAIR
Mrs. J., died February 13, 1888, aged 72 years
(No headstone; the March 2, 1888 edition of the Medina Gazette (Homer News pg. 7) tells that she was “buried at the Brethren cemetery in Chatham”.)
FORMERLY BURIED HERE…
BETZ
Frankie L., son of Isaac Jacob & Anna S., died June 27, 1890, aged 11y 7m 2d
(Per the July 11, 1890 edition of the Gazette, he drowned and was “buried in the cemetery near Rice’s mill”. He is now found buried alongside his parents in Spencer Cemetery. If he was originally buried here it is not known when his body was moved to Spencer; nor are there any clues (i.e. family connections) to indicate on what lot he might have been interred.)